Headlines Press Releases Views-Features Letters Poll

GIBRALTAR today

 

Round-the-world vessel will call at Gibraltar

  This November, the developers and builders of Nordhavn motor yachts will leave Dana Point, California on their Nordhavn 40 for a worldwide circumnavigation. It will stop at Gibraltar for a crew change before proceeding back to the States across the Atlantic.
  The purpose of the voyage is to evaluate the offshore performance of their vessel and its auxiliary equipment. Throughout the voyage, the crew will be rotated, giving a number of Nordhavn employees the opportunity of providing valuable feedback on the design and construction of this long distance passage maker.
  This 40-foot ``trawler-styled yacht'' has become one of the most popular vessels in the Nordhavn line, which consists of six models from 35 to 62 feet. A standard Nordhavn 40 costs between $450,000 and $500,000, depending on options and accessory equipment. With a range of 4,000 miles between fuel stops, it is popular with couples that want to explore distant oceans and shores.
  The circumnavigation will begin in Dana Point, California from where the boat will cross the Pacific Ocean to Hawaii and then head to the Marshall Islands, the Caroline Islands, the Philippines and Singapore. The plan is to spend New Year of 2002 in Singapore where a fresh crew will come aboard and take her to Sri Lanka, then to Djibouti and up the Red Sea to Greece. From Greece she will travel the Mediterranean, stopping in Gibraltar. Here, a third crew will board her for a trip across the Atlantic Ocean, through the Panama Canal and finally back to California for a homecoming in May of 2002. (12.08.01)



Fair trial, say International Jurists

  Court procedures in the case over the Gibraltar chief justice derek Schofield "conformed to international standards of due process," says a statement from the International Commission of Jurists. Mr Schofield is facing a charge of driving a car without a test certificate. The case continues in November. 

  The International Commission of Jurists (ICJ) says it has noted the ruling of the Magistrates’ Court in Gibraltar dated 8 August with regard to proceedings involving Chief Justice, Derek Schofield. These proceedings were observed by the ICJ.

  "The ICJ is satisfied that court procedures conformed to international standards of due process. The trial observer also noted that, consistent with the principle that all citizens are equal before the law, neither prosecution nor defence counsel asserted that the office of the defendant (ie Chief Justice), was material to proceedings," says the statement.

  It adds: This appears at some variance with the content of the magistrate’s ruling which may be construed as suggesting the contrary. It refers, inter alia, to defence submissions requesting "a degree of advantage" based solely on the Chief Justice’s constitutional position.

  The ICJ will continue to follow developments in the case.

  On 8 August Stipendiary Magistrate Anthony E. Dudley of the Magistrates' Court of Gibraltar, ruled against the application of Chief Justice Schofield for a stay of prosecution in proceedings against him for a violation of the Motor Vehicles Test Regulations.

  The application for a stay of prosecution was considered from 26 to 28 July. The ICJ, through its trial observer Justice Robert Nicholson of Australia, observed proceedings on 26-27 July.

  The ICJ’s mandate includes the promotion and protection of the independence of judges worldwide. The observer was tasked with monitoring proceedings to determine that they were being conducted in accordance with international standards relating to the right of a defendant to a fair trial. (10.08.01)

 Nuclear blunder as 'ghost of Tireless' haunts Navy


  Naval dockyard operators have admitted an embarrassing blunder during the rebuilding of a submarine's nuclear reactor. A fault in the heart of HMS Torbay's reactor has been discovered only at the end of the three-year refit. 
  The entire reactor must be dismantled and rebuilt, causing a three-month hold-up at Devonport Dockyard in Plymouth. The Torbay is the same class as the Tireless - and its fault is similar to that which kept Tireless in Gibraltar for a year.
  The problem is understood to involve a faulty control rod drive in the reactor, said the BBC. 
  Independent nuclear expert John Large, who was hired to advise during the Gibraltar controversy, said: "It's egg on the face for the navy that such a problem has been discovered after the boat has been finished. Someone does a test and says one of the control rods isn't working, and they have to take it all to pieces again. 
  HMS Torbay was one of four Trafalgar class hunter-killer sumbarines found to have faults in their reactor cooling systems. 
  The same fault controversially stranded HMS Tireless in Gibraltar last year. 
  Mr Large said: "When HMS Tireless came up it affected not only all the other boats with the same problem, but every boat waiting for a refit. He said the oversight was extraordinary. (10.08.01)

'Clamp landed in my front garden,' says housing association chairman

  A serious controversy has arisen over the parking of a  car in a parking bay at Rosia Dale, whose number plate was not registered in the Rosia Dale official books, according to a statement from Douglas Santos, chairman of the Rosia Dale housing association. It adds that Mr Payas of Group 5 was telephoned and he confirmed that he had no record of any change of number plate to any particular car. Instructions were given to clamp the car.

  "Later on in the day the police came looking for me to instruct me that I remove the clamp that had been put on the Minister Mrs Del Agua's car because she had a meeting at 6 Convent Place," says the statement.

  Subsequently, adds Mr Santos, we found that Mrs del Agua had been issued a new pass, but according to the books and also in Group 5's records there had been no change of pass. 

  Later, her husband "threw the clamp over my gate and it landed in my front garden where at that particular moment my daughter was walking through the doors leading onto the garden. There were six children playing in the area at the time," claims Mr Santos. 

  The person who issued the pass "was confronted by the committee, and the situation is being dealt with," says the statement. (10.08.01)

 

    

MENINGITIS: Family makes statement

The family of Mark Olivares, who died  last  May aged 16, have issued a statement in response to the statement by the Gibraltar health Authority. It comes through their lawyer, Daniel Feetham of Isola and Isola. It reads as follows:

"On the 8th August 2001 the GHA issued a statement in response to comments made by the Opposition about the tragic death of a young girl as a result of fulminant meningoccocol septicaemia.  In that statement the GHA stated that as always “all close contacts” with the 4 notifications of meningococcal disease this year “have been traced and given preventative medication in each instance”.

 " Mark Olivares died on the 15th May 2001 aged 16 years of age from septicaemia due to Neisseria Meningitidis Group C bacteria.  No member of the family who came into close contact with Mark immediately before his death have been either contacted by the GHA or given any preventative medicine.  To the family’s knowledge no one from Mark’s place of employment were contacted either.    "By the time that the cause of death had been diagnosed by the Consultant Pathologist, the family believed that the natural incubation period for the decease had passed.  This crucial piece of information the family learned not from advice by the GHA but from information downloaded from the Internet.  

  "Even after the diagnosis came through no one from the GHA made contact with the family in relation to preventative medication.  The family believe this is extraordinary given that Mark had two other younger brothers aged 12 and 10 who had been in close contact with him before he died.  There are other matters, which the family is concerned about in the statement from the GHA but pending their son’s inquest, they will make no further comment." (10.08.01)

Gibraltar liberalises telecoms market

  The long awaited liberalisation of Gibraltar's telecom market is now complete. It follows the passing of the relevant ordinance last month, complemented now by a number of recommendations and guidelines.

  "It represents the arrival of full liberalisation of the telecommunications industry in Gibraltar," said a Gibraltar government spokesman today.

  Telecom liberalisation is the cornerstone of Europe's transition, lowering the price of communicating and encouraging innovation and investment in new services and networks.

  A Gibraltar government statement said: "The effects of liberalisation will be felt over the coming months and it is expected that service, diversity and prices will all see improvement. Online services, notably via the internet, will see continued growth, as companies compete with each other to offer new service packages and new pricing formulae."

  The government says it views these developments as fundamental for the growth and development of an information society and is a major step for Gibraltar and the telecoms industry in general.

  The Gibraltar telecommunications ordinance 2001 provides for the assignment or conferring of functions on the Minister for Trade, Industry and Telecommunications and to the Gibraltar Regulatory Authority, which has been established as a separate legal body.

Press release in full

 (09.08.01) 

Man arrested in clamp dispute

  A 45-year old man who allegedly cut off a clamp on his car has been arrested by police.

  The incident happened at Rosia Dale when one of the residents found his car clamped. He apparently disputes that his vehicle should have been clamped. He removed the clamp and dumped it in the patio belonging to the chairman of the estate committee, it is claimed.

  A man went to police station of his own accord to explain the situation. He was arrested and is on police bail. (09.08.01) 

Undercurrent of discontent at Post Office

  There appears to be an undercurrent of discontent at the Post Office where drastic changes are planned, ostensibly to make the operation more commercially minded.

  Postal staff have for years been asking for their numbers to be increased in order to be able to cope with the mail, but this has not been met.  Their working conditions are also dismal. Sickness and leave cannot be properly met, and hence a bad situation ends up being worse.

  Presumably, as part of the new plan, money will be no object and more people will be engaged, to give the impression of a positive development after years of neglect, said sources.

  Meanwhile, clerical staff are not happy with the Government intention of not replacing postmaster Alfred Pizarro, who has chosen to retire from his post.  Clerical grades see this as the loss of one post. (09.08.01) 

Environmentalists welcome action

 The Environmental Safety Group says it welcomes the ultimatum given by the Junta de Andalucia that they will be taking legal action against the Acerinox plant in Palmones, if the radio-active ashes stored in their premises are not disposed off by the end
of September. This contaminated ash storage is a shocking situation that has been allowed to prevail for more than three years, with unknown effects on
the surrounding environment. We feel that it should be corrected immediately and preventive measures confirmed so that the population is assured that
there can be no repetition of the fiasco.
  The ESG, in association with the cross-border environmental groups, will be targetting continued pressure on the Junta de Andalucia, for them to fulfil their End of September commitment.(09.08.01)

Case against Chief Justice to be heard in November

  The Stipendiary Magistrate Anthony Dudley has today ruled on the proceedings before him in the case of the Chief Justice Derek Schofield having been summoned for using a motor vehicle without a test certificate.

  Says the Magistrate: "Somewhat surprising given the nature of the alleged offence the application before me is for a stay of the prosecution on the basis that it amounts to an abuse of the process of the court."

  He concludes: I find that there is no evidence of mala fides on the part of the Crown and that there are no exceptional circumstances or compelling reasons the defendant's application is dismissed.

  It became known during the proceedings that the Governor had written to Schofield informing him that he understood that he had been cautioned. The Magistrates says that this "is to my mind of no consequence, given that there is no indication in the letter of the Governor or evidence before me to suggest that a summons would or could result in a view being taken by the Governor which could have a negative impact upon the defendant."

  He adds: The suggestion that holding high office should in any way afford any degree of advantage whatsoever when this court exercises its discretion is in my view wholly without foundation.

  Meanwhile, solicitors for the Chief Justice have expressed surprise about aspects of the ruling of the Magistrate on the arguments of abuse of process ruled on today.

  Fabian Picardo of Hassan has confirmed that he felt compelled in court this morning to emphasise that his client has at every stage sought to be treated the same as any other individual and not in any way seeking more lenient or favourable treatment by reason of his constitutional post.

  Mr Picardo reminded the court that at the first mention of this matter in court he had made that clear for the avoidance of doubt.

  His remarks were motivated by parts of the ruling of the Magistrate which could be read to suggest the contrary.

  "The Chief Justice has always made plain his view that he must be treated no more stringently or leniently than any other party would in similar circumstances.  He would not countenance being treated in any advantageous manner by any court, and at no time has the defence submitted the contrary," said the Chief Justice's solicitors. 

Ruling in full

(08.08.01) 

'Spanish secret' to recover Rock

The ruling 'Popular Party' in Spain says they have discovered a way to recover the Rock for Spain! "The secret is to negotiate with the UK for Gibraltar to adapt its laws to those of the European Union.  From that moment, the Rock will not be economically viable for the UK and they will have to give in," said Guillermo Martinez Casan, spokesman for Europe in Spain's foreign affairs congressional committee.

  The high economic costs, he adds, will make Britain give in sooner or later.

  What this Spanish gentleman does not know, in spite of being spokesman for European Union affairs, is that Gibraltar already complies with EU laws. He also does not know that Gibraltar's finances are self-sufficient and do not depend on handouts from London.

  The Spanish MP thinks Gibraltar enjoys at present the best of both worlds. By making the Rock 'obsolete', it will fall into Spanish hands.

  The Spaniard also makes the extraordinary claim that the Governor of Gibraltar lives in the Spanish luxury housing estate of Sotogrande.

  He foresees progress in the coming months to unblock the current impasse. (07.08.01)

Port problem: Union acts

The simmering crisis at the port, as reported exclusively by us, has led to the union taking an interest.

  Action by staff appeared to have been imminent. Now, the TGWU district officer Luis Montiel, has intervened to tell the men that he was not fully aware with the seriousness and extent of the problem. He has promised that he will meet with the government on Thursday.

  This has had the effect of stalling the proposed action. Some sources expressed surprise that the union chief was not fully aware of what happens in his backyard. 

  The problem centres on staff working in 'acting' capacities for years, as well as other concerns.

  Since people in key positions would be affected, it is clear that the port could grind to a standstill if the action is proceeded with.

  Staff are now looking forward to speedy solutions to their grievances.  The fact that the problem was highlighted in PANORAMA  has clearly got action going and hopefully solutions will now be forthcoming. (07.08.01)

Port crisis looms

A major crisis is said to be looming in the port, which could result even in ships being turned away.

Reports reaching us suggest that key personnel are "fed up" that they have now been in 'acting' positions for too long -they have been waiting and waiting, but nothing gets done about the untenable situation.

The personnel concerned have been 'acting' for a senior staff. In such situations, the usual thing is for those concerned to move up the promotion ladder after a reasonable period of time, or for someone else to be appointed to the vacant post.

"ACTING" FOREVER!

"But you cannot be in an 'acting' position forever and ever!" said sources.

In fact, it is believed that some of the staff concerned have been in this unsatisfactory situation for nearly 3 years!

Apparently, they are taking the view that 'enough is enough'- and are going to refuse to take on their 'acting' duties. They will simply comply with their usual duties. No one can force them to act for someone else if they do not want to.

In such circumstances, key posts will not be filled - and essential work in the running of the port will not take place. The port could come to a grinding halt.

There are indications that shipping may not be attended to, which would mean turning vessels away from Gibraltar.

KEY OPERATIONS

It could also affect security and other vital key operations the port cannot do without.

A decision by the staff side is imminent - and unless there is sudden movement by the government to correct this anomalous situation without any further delay the port could be in trouble within 24 hours. It is that serious.

Cooperation and sovereignty go together - Piqué

While the chief minister was saying in Gibraltar that the Gibraltar government is not willing to trade sovereignty for cooperation, the Spanish foreign minister was restating in Madrid that Britain and Spain had established "with the greatest clarity that the advances in cooperation and sovereignty have to go in tandem."

He said he was "profoundly grateful" to the British government for establishing the political will that was lacking in previous meetings under the Brussels process.

Said Piqué yesterday: "Spain will never renounce the full reintegration of Gibraltar."

Asked about the isthmus, he replied: "The isthmus is Spanish territory"

He said that over Gibraltar as such, the claim of sovereignty was also unquestionable but that had to be inserted in a framework of decolonisation.

Spain had always said that she would take into account the 'interests' of the Gibraltarians (But not the 'wishes')

Caruana wants voice in the bilateral meetings and a referendum, said a Madrid daily.

Said Piqué: Two sovereign states participate in this process and there are only two delegations.

He went on: If Mr Caruana forms part of the British delegation and takes part in matters which are of his competence, not only do I not think it is bad but I even think it is convenient.

Sr Piqué said that "we are not before a process that allows the recognition of the right to self-determination."

Although there had been economic activities which, in many cases, constitute unfair competition which we have to denounce, "Gibraltar is a matter of sovereignty."

Any Spanish offer would be "reversible", said Sr Pique, if Britain did not keep to her part of the deal.

TELEPHONE LINES?

When will the new telephone lines be installed?

"I suppose it can be in the next few months. If we can advance in matters of cooperation, it is only logical that we meet the needs of the population. But there will not be unfair competition as regards Spanish operators. What is important is that the UK is conscious that for these issues to advance it is indispensable that we advance in matters related to sovereignty., " replied Pique.

FRONTIER CONTROLS?

"They will continue because Gibraltar is not part of the customs Union or Schengen. Let no one think that they are applied for political reasons. We are obliged to do so " said Pique.

CM: Working against those working groups

PANORAMA said last Monday that Anglo-Spanish working parties were to be constituted to consider a series of issues which we were first to name: The Economy, Finance, Communications, Environment, Military matters...

Last Friday, the Spanish foreign minister Josep Piqué confirmed the areas for discussion.

But the chief minister Peter Caruana says the Foreign Office has told him, again, that such working parties have not been established.

In our report last Monday we mentioned that each country would appoint a co-ordinator to monitor progress. The existence of a UK and a Spanish coordinator was confirmed by a Gibraltar government statement on Friday.

In fact, Britain expects that the two co-ordinators will meet in September to begin discussions on setting up a negotiating framework for future meetings.. it seems to confirm everything!

However, the Gibraltar government says that "Anglo-Spanish committees are not an appropriate mechanism through which to conduct mutually beneficial cooperation between Spain and Gibraltar. "The Gibraltar government could not participate in a process that was so structured," said the chief minister's office.

At the end of the London talks last month, foreign secretary Jack Straw said that "what we set out is an agenda of cooperation and economic issues as well as other constitutional issues such as sovereignty as part of this framework." Sr Piqué spoke of "working groups being set-up by the two governments."

PSOE Fears "Cheap Calls"

The Spanish opposition party PSOE has rallied behind the Spanish Government in respect of the offer of telephone lines to Gibraltar, so long Spain was not adversely affected.

Rafael Estrella, PSOE Foreign Affairs spokesman conditioned it to the extra lines not being used for "unfair competition."

He would be against Gibraltar taking advantage of Spanish goodwill to promote its "fiscal paradise" and convert itself in "a center for cheap calls."

 
Why Government's phone position shifted

The Opposition is surprised that Mr Caruana should claim that the Government has not shifted its position on the question of telephone numbers. It is a matter of public record that in February this year the Government was opposed to a political agreement with Spain over the 350 code which did not test the matter in court, and in May Mr Caruana changed his position and supported such a political agreement. The recent Government statement issued in response to Mr Pique's offer of more lines shows that the Government has reverted to the original position it held in February.
  When the shortage of telephone numbers was discussed in the House of Assembly this February, both the Government and the Opposition adopted a
similar position. This was that the offer of more telephone numbers by Spain or the possible use of the 44 code for calls from Spain only was only
acceptable as an interiim solution provided by the European Court once legal proceedings had been commenced against Spain. Mr Caruana said at the
time: "Interim and litigation, yes. Interim in a political process, no."
  In the House of Assembly in May this year, Mr Caruana said that a position paper was being put to the Spanish Government, with his support, in an effort to resolve the shortage of telephone numbers. The Chief
Minister then said that he was willing to see the 0044 code adopted for calls from Spain without the European Commission having first initiated legal proceedings against Spain. When challenged by the Opposition at the time Mr Caruana accused the Opposition of wanting to hold out on this issue regardless of the cost to Gibraltar and that this was not an approach that
would allow Gibraltar to survive.
  Last week, in response to the offer of more telephone lines by the Spanish Foreign Minister Josep Pique, Mr Caruana abandoned the position he had held in May, and reverted to the original position he had adopted in
February. When he refused the offer of more telephone lines from Spain, Mr Caruana said that the way forward was through the enforcement of Gibraltar's legal rights in this area and added that Mr Pique's statement
confirmed that Madrid had been acting illegally all along in refusing to recognise Gibraltar's international code 350.
  The Opposition want to make clear that the Government will enjoy its full backing and support on the basis of the defence of Gibraltar's legal rights
in this field. In can only be in the best interests of Gibraltar to have Government and Opposition working together in such a sensitive and important matter.
(06.08.01)

Should Catalan Bay close down?

A reader has informed us that viral infections are being contracted by bathers who go to Catalan Bay. It is believed that the water needs to be tested.

The Government, we are told, knows about it, but they do not want to take any action as it would mean closing the beach down.

Airliner in take-off scare

  An airliner had to abort on taking off from Gibraltar when one of its engines sucked a seagull.

  Passengers were disembarked yesterday to allow for engineering checks.  The flight was resumed today.

  Gibraltar is a popular spot for seagulls - and their presence in the airport area has long been seen as a danger.  The pilot in this case spotted the problem and avoided what could have been a major crisis..

  The authorities have been refusing to provide information about the incident involving a Monarch flight to Luton, UK, said a Gibraltar radio report.(06.08.01) 

Gibraltar offers VAT-free carrot to Freeserve in row over AOL

 GIBRALTAR is trying to tempt Freeserve to relocate to the Rock, presenting itself as a solution to the internet company's Vat dispute with the British government on its treatment of America Online (AOL), reports the Sunday Times.

Last week an official of the government of Gibraltar wrote to John Pluthero, Freeserve's chief executive, urging him to investigate the tax advantages of moving. Gibraltar has low taxes and does not levy Vat. It is keen to establish itself as a centre for technology and telecommunications companies. 

The paper names Darion Figueredo of Gibraltar's ministry of trade, industry and telecommunications as having written " his opportunistic letter after reading of Freeserve's dispute with AOL. Freeserve is furious that AOL has an unfair advantage because the American company does not have to charge Vat to its British customers, who number more than a million. This is because Customs & Excise has treated it as a content provider, rather than as a telecoms company." 

Freeserve claims this means AOL enjoys a tax advantage of at least £26m. The British company argues that there is no justification for this discrimination. It points out that even AOL's website states that it offers unmetered access to the internet - a service that clearly falls within the definition of a telecoms company. 
  Freeserve, which is now owned by Wanadoo of France, said it had no plans to abandon Britain. However, the dispute underlines the problems posed by tax arbitrage, said the report.

Figueredo said Gibraltar recognised that it was too small to allow any major telecoms company to relocate its main operations. However, it still hopes to attract smaller parts of the leading multinationals.

Meanwhile, Customs & Excise in Britain has admitted it is concerned about the Vat anomaly, and does not want to see a British firm disadvantaged. However, it has to work within European Union tax law. (05.08.01)

Opposition call for unity to take Spain to court

  The Opposition maintain that the solution to the telecommunications problems which Gibraltar is experiencing can be solved in an instant if
Spain recognises our international telephone code 350. "The Opposition agree with the Government that the recognition and enforcement of Gibraltar's
legal rights in this field is the way forward," says opposition leader Joe Bossano.

The Spanish Foreign Minister Josep Piqué has indicated that the telephone issue is one for discussion under the framework of the relaunched Brussels process and has made an offer to Gibraltar of a few "tens of thousands" of
lines. The Opposition welcome that the Gibraltar Government has rebuffed this offer.

An alliance statement adds: This will allow Government and Opposition in Gibraltar to maintain a united front on this matter. It will be recalled that the House of Assembly was united around one position in February and that this was abandoned a few weeks later when Mr Caruana stated that the United Kingdom was negotiating with Spain with his support the possible use of the 0044 code or extra numbers.
  It is a good thing for Gibraltar that the Government has now reverted to their original position, and they can count on the full support of the Opposition in seeking the enforcement of Gibraltar's EU rights.

The Opposition sasy they remain of the view that Spain must be taken to the European Court over its failure to recognise the 350 code. Given that this process may take years, the Court is a position, once the legal action has commenced, to grant Gibraltar interim relief. This relief may take the form
of extra telephone numbers from Spain. 

  "However, there is a vital distinction between Spain granting Gibraltar more telephone numbers because she wants to, and Spain being forced by a court to do so as part of a process of interim relief. The latter will lead to a resolution of the problem, whereas the former will lead to more problems again when the new lines run out," said Mr Bossano.

The Opposition are happy that the Gibraltar Government has come back to the position that it adopted in February. It can only be in the best
interests of Gibraltar to have the whole House of Assembly united in such a serious matter.

(03.08.01)

LAST WEEKS STORIES 

Search





 

  • Books

  • Magazines

  • Posters & Prints

 

 

Top